The Sons of Silenus – The Sidekick Hero

The Sons of Silenus – The Sidekick Hero

The Sidekick hero.

Frequently thought of as the lowly sidekick. Yet he is the hero’s “shield on shoulder and right-hand man,” his monkey wrench in a bad fight when most he needs one. The guy the hero knows will always be there no matter what. The son he never had and more brother than any sibling of his own flesh. Holmes without Watson is unthinkable.  You can’t conceive of the Lone Ranger without Tonto at his side. Jim West always had Artie covering his back. And while Batman without Robin happens on occasion, they always end up inserting Robin eventually.  

So, what is a Sidekick hero? 

What is his function? 

And why does any hero need one?

The answer to the first question depends on what does the main hero need that he lacks?  The type of sidekick a hero needs generally falls into two broad categories.  The Protégé and the Best (and often only) Friend

However, there is one universal trait that both categories share.  They act as a go-between, either between the hero and his audience or the hero and his world.

The Protégé:

An adolecent Robin seems like an incomprehensibly irresponsible choice of sidekick today, but you have to remember there actually was a time that young boys read comic books.  Now, it’s a market (if it can even be called that) dominated by middle-aged men but comic books used to be for boys.  Boys always like to pretend they are their favorite hero, but twenty years age difference is a monstrous gulf for even the most imaginative of children to overcome. It creates a gap for them. But 1940s Dick Grayson filled that gap. He was their age, it was no real stretch to put themselves in his shoes and fight crime alongside Batman.

And let’s be clear, Robin was immensely popular when he was introduced.  Suddenly every hero had a boy wonder battling evil with him.  So, Robin acted as an intermediary between Batman and his core audience, at first.   However, as time went on, he began to fill the narrative as Batman’s go-between with humanity.   He could make the darker versions of Batman see the light of regular people.  He could show Batman that he was doing good in the world even when it felt like he wasn’t.  Eventually, Robin became his own man as Nightwing fulfilling the other function of a protégé which is to grow up and become a hero in his own right, taking what character traits he wants to emulate from his father-figure and rejecting those things he doesn’t want to be.  Sometimes this clears the decks for a new sidekick that can conform to what his hero needs from him in his current incarnation.  Tim Drake (unlike his immediate predecessor) fulfilled this function magnificently.

Eventually, the Protégés had to change with the times. In the ensuing decades, an adolescent sidekick became unacceptable to modern sensibilities so past a certain point they were never younger than sixteen years old.  Legally a minor, but generally viewed as an acceptably capable one. These older Protégés still filled the function of being a pseudo-child, although they now came equipped with teenage problems. This let comic book publishers pretend they were attracting a teenage audience when they weren’t. However, in the 80s and 90s, there was some success in this regard with teen protégés banding together as their own team.

But there was one thing that a Protégé could never be…

The Best Friend:

The Detective Hero in particular always needs the go-between function from his Sidekick. Because as I have stated before, the Detective Hero is always a defective hero.  Holmes needed Watson for a lot more than exposition to his audience.  He needed Watson simply to connect with people in general.  Emotional outreach was always impossible for Sherlock Holmes, he desperately needed John Watson to keep in touch, not just with the human race but his own humanity as well.

Although, being a doctor, Watson brought a few more things to the table.  Primarily a knowledge base that Holmes doesn’t have regarding medicine. 

This is often the function of Best Friend Sidekick.  Take Tonto for instance. He brought with him extensive native knowledge, lore, and abilities. However, Tonto was also a lot more. The Lone Ranger is unusual in being both an Explorer hero and a Detective hero.  The Explorer is always a man with one foot in two worlds, the realms of Law and Chaos, and he enforces the border between them. However, the Detective hero is always firmly planted in the realm of Law.  Which put the Lone Ranger mostly on one side of the border he must guard.  He needed Tonto as his inseparable best friend to balance this out.  

The go-between function of the Sidekick is his most important trait.  

So, if the Sidekick is so badly needed by his hero, why is viewed as the “lowly sidekick.”

Because everyone sees himself as the hero of his own story.  

And we see just a little too much of ourselves in the Sidekick.  

This post would not have been possible without the invaluable resource that is Professor Geek’s podcast.  The Dark Herald Recommends with Enthusiasm.

Share this post

Comments (8)

  • Linguavert Reply

    I started listening to Professor Geek after you mentioned him in a previous post. And now I’d like to thank you for that.

    January 6, 2022 at 4:44 pm
  • John E Boyle Reply

    Very interesting series of articles, Herald. Thank you.

    January 6, 2022 at 5:08 pm
  • Robert W Reply

    Ironman has War Machine, Dr. Strange has his monks, Capt had Bucky then Falcon, Marvel was stacked with sidekicks.
    Except for Peter Parker. Is this because he already was deeply indentifiable for the audience and a sidekick would not add anything?

    January 6, 2022 at 9:10 pm
    • Val Reply

      In the Avengers films, Peter Parker is Tony Stark’s protégé particularly once War Machine gets paralyzed. In his own films, which I haven’t actually seen, he has the chubby Mexican classmate for a sidekick.

      January 7, 2022 at 12:17 am
    • Nom Reply

      I think Spider-Man is an Everyman in a way most superheroes aren’t. Most comic superheroes get frozen in their canonical role – they can’t progress too far without becoming something different. Spider-Man’s role is the protege without a mentor – the boy trying to become a man is core to his identity. To have a sidekick is to move into true manhood and thus cease to be Spider-man as we know him. For comparison, note that part of the appeal of Luke Skywalker is that he remains a protege throughout the original trilogy. The OT ends when Luke finishes his apprenticeship and becomes senior in his relationships

      January 7, 2022 at 10:19 am
    • The Dark Herald Reply

      There were two reasons that Spiderman didn’t have a sidekick.

      First, he was roughly sixteen when he got bit. Consequently, he was a too young to have a Protégé of his own and his best friend couldn’t be that much help against the Green Goblin.

      Second, and more critically important. Stan Lee HATED sidekicks.

      January 7, 2022 at 12:34 pm
      • Patrick McNally Reply

        Stan Lee used Rick Jones as a sidekick for the Hulk and Captain America, so it doesn’t seem that he hated them that much.

        January 7, 2022 at 11:41 pm
  • Linguavert Reply

    Last year, I read “The Roman Way” by Edith Hamilton. One of the chapters was about Roman drama and Roman audiences’ love of the slave character. In comedies, the slave was usually the smartest, funniest, wittiest and most resourceful character — the one whom the master could rely on to get everyone out of trouble and to save the day. (How Romans could balance this with the brutal way they treated slaves in real life may require another book!) I was reading “The Roman Way” while rewatching the MCU movies, and I couldn’t help thinking that if an Ancient Roman saw “Civil War”, he’d recognize in Peter Parker a younger version of the same archetype that made the slave character so popular.

    In our age, when all characters are free and “master” means not owner, but mentor, the sidekick hero is not a slave, but a son. And one whom we would all love to see as a mature man someday.

    January 7, 2022 at 2:05 pm

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *